‘Perception is reality’ and ‘the customer is always right’. Two tenets Contact Energy’s board failed to consider when they tried to push through a significant pay increase for themselves whilst increasing prices by over 10% last year.
It cost them dearly. Not only did they lose around 41,000 customers and millions of dollars, they also lost a massive amount of goodwill and severely damaged their reputation. The long-term effects will be significant.
When a telemarketing company phoned me a few weeks ago trying to entice me to switch from my current energy provider to Contact I let her know I wasn’t interested for one reason only: what I considered to be the behaviour of the board in thumbing their noses at their customers and shareholders. She seemed quite surprised I was so specific. “I’ll pass that on” she said. ‘Yes, please do’ said I.
Whilst Contact was left scratching its head at the customer exodus, other energy companies that took a customer perspective clearly benefited as a result.
If each of those 41,000 customers paid, on average, $400 a year for their power, Contact would have lost over $16 million. Multiply that by, say, 4 years (before the customer’s inertia cuts in and they decide to switch providers) and could lose more than $65 million. Quite a sum to throw away.
Business editor, Liam Dann’s comments in his New Zealand Herald article hit the nail on the head:
“… managing director David Baldwin was forced to publicly concede that the losses were linked to the high-profile efforts of the board to ram through large fee increases in the face of widespread shareholder opposition. The admission is one which confirms a monumental failing of the board. It acted in its own self-interest and ultimately in a manner which was damaging to the company.”
That about sums it up! Not only did they lose immediate and longer-term revenue, the reputational damage is enormous. Indeed, another Herald report notes:
“… the fallout following last year directors’ fee shambles was the worst blow to its reputation in the company’s history.”
Lines company Vector, on the other hand, read the mood of its shareholders and customers more accurately and dropped its proposed directors’ fees increases before its meeting, winning praise – and no doubt customers – in the process.
Dann’s article concludes:
“It is about keeping up with social trends and behaviour and staying in tune with the mood of the people. After all the people, if nothing else, are the customers.”
I totally agree. Perception is reality and the customer is always right … in their opinion. Forget this at your peril. The sound of departing customers can be thunderous or silent. Either way, you may find yourself with fewer, if any, to argue with.